Historic porch restorations and freestanding deck designs for Arts District homes
WTS II Contracting is a licensed Michigan residential builder specializing in custom deck and porch construction throughout Three Oaks, utilizing freestanding deck design that creates structurally independent platforms butting against historic homes without ledger board attachment, eliminating stress on fragile fieldstone foundations and preserving the architectural integrity of Arts District properties, with comprehensive expertise in Village of Three Oaks lot coverage regulations and setback requirements for downtown historic district construction. Our historic preservation approach—featuring tongue-and-groove composite porch flooring that mimics tight gaps of original 1920s wood planks, modern farmhouse aesthetics combining white composite railings with black aluminum balusters, and structural porch restoration techniques that jack sagging roofs and install code-compliant footings while maintaining period-appropriate appearance—creates outdoor living spaces engineered for contemporary use while respecting Three Oaks' celebrated architectural heritage.
| Specification | Details |
|---|---|
| Permit Jurisdiction | Village of Three Oaks OR Three Oaks Township—verify on tax bill |
| Home Style | Historic bungalow, farmhouse, Victorian (1900s-1930s construction common) |
| Structural Preference | Freestanding (non-ledger) design to protect old foundations and framing |
| Aesthetic Goal | Modern farmhouse—white composite railing with black balusters, dark decking |
| Porch Flooring | Tongue-and-groove composite (narrow width boards mimicking historic appearance) |
| Code Compliance | 36" minimum railing height (modern safety code) with historic-sensitive design |
| Typical Timeline | 3–5 weeks (includes historic assessment, freestanding foundation, custom details) |
Three Oaks' Arts District features beautifully renovated bungalows and farmhouses from the 1900s-1930s, many built on fieldstone or mortared brick foundations that are structurally inadequate for modern deck ledger attachment. Standard deck construction bolting heavy ledger boards to these foundations destroys historic masonry and creates dangerous structural conditions.
The historic foundation characteristics:
The ledger attachment failure sequence on historic foundations:
The problem compounds with historic preservation considerations: damaging original foundation material reduces property value in Arts District where architectural authenticity commands premium prices. Once historic masonry is drilled and damaged, restoration is expensive and often impossible to match original construction methods.
WTS II Contracting builds freestanding deck structures that protect historic foundations:
Freestanding Deck Design Principles:
Freestanding Foundation System:
Weather Sealing Without Attachment:
Cost Comparison:
For Three Oaks Arts District properties where architectural integrity is paramount, freestanding deck design is the only responsible approach that respects both structural safety and historic preservation.
Many Three Oaks bungalows feature original 1920s front porches that have settled 2-6 inches over 100 years due to inadequate foundations—wood stumps, stacked brick without footings, or shallow concrete pads above frost line. These sagging porches create drainage problems, door operation issues, and dangerous trip hazards requiring comprehensive structural restoration.
The historic porch failure patterns:
The complications of porch restoration on historic homes:
WTS II Contracting's systematic porch restoration approach:
Phase 1: Structural Assessment and Planning
Phase 2: Roof Support and Demolition
Phase 3: New Foundation Installation
Phase 4: Structural Framing
Phase 5: Column Installation—Modern Materials with Historic Appearance
Phase 6: Finishing Details
Cost Analysis for Historic Porch Restoration:
Three Oaks bungalows built 1900-1940 typically use balloon frame construction where wall studs run continuously from foundation to roof with floor joists nailed to studs—no solid band joist or rim board for modern ledger attachment. This creates both structural inadequacy and concealed rot that makes standard deck ledger installation impossible.
The balloon frame characteristics:
The attempt to attach ledger to balloon frame:
WTS II Contracting's solutions for balloon-frame homes:
Option 1: Freestanding Deck (Preferred)
Option 2: Structural Header Installation (If Attachment Required)
Option 3: Rot Repair Before Ledger (If Rim Exists)
Three Oaks Arts District commands premium property values due to architectural authenticity—beautifully restored bungalows and farmhouses where every detail contributes to period character. Standard pressure-treated lumber with 1/4-inch gaps between boards looks jarringly modern and cheap against renovated Victorian or Craftsman architecture, destroying the visual continuity that makes these properties valuable.
The aesthetic mismatch problems:
WTS II Contracting specifies tongue-and-groove composite porch flooring that authentically replicates historic appearance:
TimberTech Porch Collection:
Aeratis Porch Flooring (Alternative):
Modern Farmhouse Aesthetic (Current Trend):
This combination creates the contemporary "modern farmhouse" aesthetic popular in Arts District renovations—respecting historic proportions and color schemes while providing zero-maintenance modern materials.
Cost comparison (12x16 porch, 192 sq ft):
Three Oaks has strict dual jurisdiction with Village of Three Oaks and Three Oaks Township enforcing significantly different lot coverage limits—particularly stringent in Village downtown/Arts District where preserving small-town character requires limiting structure footprints.
Lot Coverage Definition:
The violation sequence:
Village vs Township Differences:
WTS II Contracting verifies lot coverage compliance before design:
Historic Three Oaks porches typically feature 30-inch railings appropriate for 1920s standards but below current 36-inch minimum required by Michigan Residential Code. Replacing historic railings with code-compliant versions while maintaining period-appropriate appearance requires careful design.
The code vs aesthetics conflict:
WTS II Contracting designs code-compliant railings that minimize visual impact:
Slim Profile Top Rails:
Maximum Baluster Spacing:
Horizontal Cable Systems (Modern Homes):
White Composite with Black Balusters (Most Popular):
Historic Replication (Period Accuracy):
We use contractor-grade materials that respect historic aesthetics while providing modern performance:
Yes, structural repairs to porches require a building permit from either the Village of Three Oaks or Three Oaks Township depending on your property location. Michigan Residential Code classifies porch reconstruction as structural work requiring plan review and inspections—this includes foundation replacement, framing modifications, and railing upgrades even if maintaining same footprint. What triggers permit requirements: (1) Foundation work—replacing deteriorated footings, adding new posts, correcting settlement, (2) Structural framing—replacing floor joists, beams, or support columns, (3) Roof modifications—altering porch roof structure or attachment to house, (4) Railing replacement—safety-critical component requiring inspection for code compliance (36-inch minimum height, 4-inch sphere rule). Inspections required: Footing inspection before concrete pour (verify 42-inch depth), framing inspection before flooring installation (verify joist spacing and connections), final inspection after railing installation (verify height and baluster spacing). Why permits matter: Unpermitted work discovered during home sale delays closing—buyers' lenders require resolution. Structural failures on unpermitted porches create liability issues. Village of Three Oaks enforces lot coverage limits during permit review—building without permits may result in violations requiring removal. WTS II Contracting handles all permit applications, plan submissions, and coordinates inspections with appropriate jurisdiction.
Yes, we use modern composites milled to look like historic tongue-and-groove lumber—maintaining period-appropriate appearance while providing zero-maintenance performance. The challenge with historic bungalows: original porch floors used 3-4 inch wide tongue-and-groove planks with tight joints and hidden nails—creating seamless appearance nothing like modern 5.5-inch deck boards with 1/4-inch gaps and visible screws. WTS II Contracting's historic replication approach: (1) TimberTech Porch Collection—3.5-inch tongue-and-groove composite boards that interlock creating tight joints identical to original wood. Hidden clip fasteners attach to tongue—completely concealed from above. Smooth paint-grade finish accepts any exterior paint color to match historic schemes, (2) Aeratis Porch Flooring—PVC-based tongue-and-groove in 4-inch widths. Factory primed ready for painting. Perfect for traditional white porch floors common on Craftsman bungalows, (3) PVC column wraps—cellular PVC sleeves over structural posts available in square, tapered, or turned profiles matching original columns. Paint to match trim color—never rot or split like wood, (4) White composite railings—modern farmhouse aesthetic using white top/bottom rails with black aluminum balusters. Creates period-appropriate painted appearance with zero maintenance. The result: porches that respect 1920s architectural proportions and details while using materials that will last 40-50 years without refinishing, painting, or board replacement—authentic historic appearance with contemporary performance.
Yes, it puts zero stress on the old framing or foundation—critically important for Three Oaks historic homes with fieldstone foundations, balloon-frame construction, or deteriorated rim joists. Standard deck construction bolts heavy ledger boards to house structure, creating lateral loads and attachment stresses that historic buildings were never designed to support. Why freestanding is safer for old homes: (1) Protects fragile foundations—fieldstone and mortared brick crumble when drilled for ledger bolts. Freestanding decks don't touch foundation at all, (2) No structural modifications required—balloon-frame homes lack solid rim joist for attachment. Freestanding design eliminates need to alter original framing, (3) Prevents moisture intrusion—ledger board penetrations through siding create water entry points. Freestanding decks butt against house with weather seal but no penetrations, (4) Preserves architectural integrity—no bolts through historic masonry, no damage to original materials, maintains structure's historic authenticity, (5) Independent load path—deck supported entirely by its own foundation system. House foundation carries only house weight, deck loads completely separate. How freestanding works: Deck posts and footings located 12-18 inches away from house foundation. Front beam parallel to house carries half of deck load. Deck rim joist butts against house siding with 1/2-inch gap—flexible sealant provides weather barrier without structural connection. Cost premium: $600-1,200 for typical 12x16 deck (additional front beam and footings) but prevents foundation damage on irreplaceable historic structures valued $300,000-800,000+ in Three Oaks Arts District.
WTS II Contracting also serves surrounding communities. Learn about our deck building services in:
Get a detailed estimate from a licensed Michigan residential builder who specializes in historic preservation—freestanding deck designs that protect old foundations, tongue-and-groove composite flooring that mimics 1920s appearance, and modern farmhouse aesthetics perfect for Arts District properties.
Request Your Free Estimate